The Hidden Palace is Helene Wecker’s follow-up to The Golem & the Jinni, and picks up just where it left off, with the story of practical, compassionate golem Chava and of wild, restless jinni Ahmad. Sophia Winston leaves for the Middle East to seek some sort of cure for the illness that leaves her forever cold. New stories are introduced: a young, ambitious Jewish girl begins to explore dark magics with her father, while Anna’s son Toby begins to dig at the mysteries of his birth, and a jinniyeh across the sea learns she’s immune to iron.
To start, a tough but honest critique: truthfully, this book begins very slow. Similar to its predecessor, it’s focused on telling many tales and then weaving them into one building thread, and I dedicated some thought to why that approach feels more scattered in this novel. I think that it is partially due to the long timeline, 1900–1915, but primarily it is because we already know some of these characters, and so there is less of an overlying mystery to power the story—instead, it is guided purely by interest in the characters, waiting to see how it will eventually tie to a central point. Instead of unfolding answers, it’s more about waiting to see what conflict will arrive, waiting for a climatic point.
Luckily, anyone who loved the first story of the golem and the jinni will love this one too. Wecker’s newest brings up fascinating new questions about trying to fit in, about assimilation and its costs, about the ways people change as they immigrate. Chava feels she must blend in seamlessly to not be found out, and so her lack of aging puts her at risk; Ahmad doesn’t understand why they must put so much of their true natures aside for the sake of their neighbors. What balance can they find? As those they love grow older around them, as the world itself begins to change, Chava and Ahmad struggle to adjust with it. Wecker’s stunning writing continues to pull the reader along, her elegant world immersive as ever. While I found the jinni even more annoying in this book than the last, his character development is rewarding, and feels very real, and I loved reading about Chava finding her place in the world. Readers who loved The Golem and the Jinni will read this one eagerly cover-to-cover.
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The Hidden Palace comes out June 8, 2021.